Osborne Effect

Osborne Effect

Announce a shiny new product too early and customers stop buying the current one to wait for it. That's the Osborne Effect, and it can sink a company.

Why buy today's model when a better one is coming? That simple thought, multiplied across thousands of customers, is the Osborne Effect. When a company announces a new product or version too far ahead of its release, sales of what it's selling right now can dry up as people wait. It's most common in tech, and it's named after the Osborne Computer Corporation, which got caught this way in the early 1980s.

A few examples:

  1. A phone maker announces a new model with game-changing features, due in six months. Would-be buyers hold off, and sales of the current phone drop.

  2. A car company unveils a new electric vehicle with better range and performance, launching next year. People shopping with that brand postpone their purchase, and sales of the existing lineup fall.

  3. A console maker announces a next-generation machine with better graphics and gameplay, out in a year. Gamers stop buying the current console and wait.

The lesson: talking up the future too early can starve the present, and in the worst cases push a company into financial trouble.

The Osborne Effect is a real risk, but the story it's named after may not be the best example of it. Several people close to Osborne Computer have argued the famous announcement wasn't what killed the company.

  1. The origin story is disputedIn 1983 Adam Osborne talked up the next-generation Executive while the Osborne 1 was still the company's main product, and sales of the old machine reportedly stalled. That's the legend. But in 2005 The Register, drawing on Osborne's own 1985 memoir Hypergrowth (co-written with John C. Dvorak), told a different story. The new model had shipped and the company was starting to turn a profit when a vice president found roughly $150,000 worth of old motherboards and decided to build them into machines, spending around $2 million the company couldn't afford. Osborne called it throwing good money after bad, a textbook case of the sunk cost fallacy. Note that this account comes from Osborne and his co-author, who had their own reasons to tell it this way.

  2. Competition and pricing mattered tooFormer employee Mike McCarthy, interviewed by columnist Robert X. Cringely in 2005, pointed to Kaypro. Its machine had a bigger screen and cost about $400 less than the Executive, and it was already eating into Osborne's sales. On this view, customers didn't just wait; they went elsewhere.

  3. One vivid story, many causesCompanies usually fail for several reasons at once: cash flow, competition, pricing, management. A memorable explanation like "they announced too early" is easy to recall and repeat, which is exactly how the availability bias works, and it makes it tempting to confuse what happened first with what caused the collapse, a form of the correlation-causation fallacy.

  4. Pre-announcing doesn't always backfireDvorak has said he knew of no case where a pre-announcement alone sank a company, noting that IBM and Microsoft pre-announced products without harm. When it's handled well, lost sales of the old product are offset by orders for the new one once it ships. Companies also pre-announce for good reasons: to reassure existing customers, attract investors or keep competitors guessing.

  5. The effect does show up elsewhereOther cases are often cited as clearer examples, from North Star Computers in 1978, whose sales of an existing controller stopped after it announced a better one, to Sega publicly discussing the Dreamcast while the Saturn was still on sale. Most of the evidence is case histories and journalism rather than systematic research, so how often and how strongly it happens is hard to pin down.

The balanced view: announcing too early can genuinely freeze current sales, especially for a small company with thin cash reserves. But the Osborne Computer story is more tangled than the legend, and "never pre-announce" is too strong a rule.

Resources

The Osborne Effect is what happens when a company announces a new or improved product too early: sales of the current product slump because customers decide to wait (Osborne, 1985). It's named after the Osborne Computer Corporation, which announced a new computer model too soon in the early 1980s, an episode that ended in the company's bankruptcy (Chposky & Leonsis, 1985).

The effect ties into consumer behavior, information cascades and the diffusion of innovations.

Start with consumer behavior. Customers weigh purchases by a product's perceived value (Solomon, 2014). Announce something better and the current product's value drops overnight, so people put off buying.

Information cascades make it worse. People often decide based on what they see others doing (Banerjee, 1992; Bikhchandani et al., 1992). If customers notice others holding out for the new model, they hold out too, and the slump snowballs, a version of the bandwagon effect running in reverse.

There's also a link to diffusion of innovations theory, which studies how new ideas and technologies spread through channels over time (Rogers, 2003). An early announcement disrupts that process: customers who would have adopted the current product wait for the next one instead.

The lesson for companies is to time announcements carefully and manage expectations so the handover between product generations is smooth.

References

  • Banerjee, A. V. (1992). A Simple Model of Herd Behavior. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 107(3), 797-817.
  • Bikhchandani, S., Hirshleifer, D., & Welch, I. (1992). A Theory of Fads, Fashion, Custom, and Cultural Change as Informational Cascades. Journal of Political Economy, 100(5), 992-1026.
  • Chposky, J., & Leonsis, T. (1985). Blue Magic: The People, Power, and Politics Behind the IBM Personal Computer. Facts on File Publications.
  • Osborne, A. (1985). Hypergrowth: The Rise and Fall of the Osborne Computer Corporation. Idthekkethan Publishing Company.
  • Rogers, E. M. (2003). Diffusion of Innovations (5th ed.). Free Press.
  • Solomon, M. R. (2014). Consumer Behavior: Buying, Having, and Being (10th ed.). Pearson Education.