Optimism Bias
Optimism bias is our habit of believing good things will happen to us and bad things will happen to other people.
Most of us quietly assume that good things are more likely to happen to us than to other people, and bad things less likely. That's optimism bias.
Two everyday versions:
Health risksYou and your friends all know smoking raises the risk of lung cancer. Yet each smoker in the group may privately feel that they, personally, are less likely to get it than other smokers. Same habit, same risk, but somehow the danger belongs to someone else.
Relationship successAt a wedding, someone mentions that around half of marriages end in divorce. You nod; sounds right. But your own marriage? Surely its odds are much better. Almost everyone feels this way, which is exactly the point.
The trouble is that a rosier picture than reality justifies leads to poor decisions and too little preparation for things going wrong. Simply knowing about the bias helps you weigh the downside as seriously as the upside.
Optimism bias is one of psychology's best-known findings, and it has a respectable pile of studies behind it. But over the past fifteen years a group of researchers has argued that much of the classic evidence measures something other than optimism.
Statistical artifacts in the classic testThe standard method, dating back to Neil Weinstein's 1980 study, asks people whether they are more or less likely than the average person to suffer some misfortune. Adam Harris and Ulrike Hahn (2011) showed that because most bad events are rare, perfectly rational people with accurate information would still, as a group, look "optimistic" on this test.
When artifacts are controlled, the effect fadesIn a 2017 PLOS ONE paper, Harris, Laura de Molière, Melinda Soh and Hahn ran five studies designed to remove those artifacts and found no evidence that the comparative method was picking up a genuinely motivational optimism. In two of the studies, severe outcomes were even judged more likely than neutral ones.
The belief-updating evidence is contested tooA newer line of work, popularised by Tali Sharot, suggests people update their beliefs more after good news than bad news. Punit Shah, Harris, Geoffrey Bird, Caroline Catmur and Hahn (2016) argued in Cognitive Psychology that this pattern can also be a statistical artifact of the task. Across five experiments they found no optimistic updating, and when people rated rare positive events, they found the mirror-image "pessimistic" pattern instead, the territory of pessimism bias. Because the same task is used in many brain-imaging studies, those results become harder to interpret as well.
None of this shows that people are always realistic. Over-optimistic forecasts in projects, sports fandom and politics are easy to find. What the critics have shown is that a general, built-in optimism bias is harder to demonstrate than the textbooks suggest, and that some of the most-cited evidence may not mean what it seemed to.
Resources
Ask a room full of people whether they're more or less likely than average to get divorced, fall ill or be in a car accident, and most will say "less." They can't all be right. Optimism bias, also called unrealistic optimism, is one of the best-documented findings in social and cognitive psychology: we tend to overestimate the chances of good things happening to us and underestimate the chances of bad ones. (Its gloomier mirror image is pessimism bias.) The result is skewed risk perception, shaky plans and decisions that look worse in hindsight.
Optimism bias is tangled up with several other biases and research areas:
Illusion of controlPeople overestimate how much they can steer events, especially where control is limited or absent. This feeds optimism bias, because if you believe your skill or effort will keep trouble away, bad outcomes start to look unlikely.
Planning fallacyWe underestimate how much time or money a task will take, which produces rosy forecasts and poor planning. Optimism bias drives a lot of this, since obstacles and complications rarely make it into the forecast.
Affective forecastingPredicting how we'll feel in the future is notoriously error-prone. Optimism bias tilts these predictions, so people overestimate how intense and lasting their good feelings will be and underestimate the bad ones.
Self-serving bias: We credit our successes to internal factors (skill, effort) and blame our failures on external ones (bad luck, circumstances). That habit props up optimism bias: if your wins are down to you, it seems natural that more wins are on the way.
The stakes are highest in areas like health, finance and project management, where getting risk and planning right really matters. Knowing how optimism bias works, and how it connects to these other biases, makes it easier to judge your own situation more evenly, with the downside in view as well as the upside.
References
- Weinstein, N. D. (1980). Unrealistic optimism about future life events. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 39(5), 806-820.
- Langer, E. J. (1975). The illusion of control. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 32(2), 311-328.
- Kahneman, D., & Tversky, A. (1979). Intuitive prediction: Biases and corrective procedures. TIMS Studies in Management Science, 12, 313-327.
- Wilson, T. D., & Gilbert, D. T. (2003). Affective forecasting. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 35, 345-411.
- Miller, D. T., & Ross, M. (1975). Self-serving biases in the attribution of causality: Fact or fiction? Psychological Bulletin, 82(2), 213-225.