Wardley Map
A Wardley Map plots each part of a business by how much users need it and how mature it is, so you can see where things are heading and plan your strategy.
A Wardley Map is a picture of your business, project or system that shows two things about every part of it: how much it matters to the user, and how mature it is. Simon Wardley developed it to help people spot opportunities, risks and strategic options (think of it as a more visual cousin of a SWOT analysis), and it's used in business strategy, project planning and technology decisions.
Let's make it concrete. Say you own a small bakery and want to stay competitive and grow.
A Wardley Map breaks your bakery into its components and places them on a grid with two axes:
The horizontal axis shows evolution, from brand-new and custom-made (Genesis) on the left to standardized and widely available (Commodity) on the right.
The vertical axis shows the value chainthings the customer sees and cares about directly go at the top, supporting infrastructure further down.
For the bakery, you might map:
- Bread recipes (your own creations, toward the Genesis end)
- Baking equipment (mature and standard, toward the Commodity end)
- Customer service (close to the customer)
- Supplier management (further from the customer)
Once everything is on the map, the options jump out. You might decide to:
- Pour creativity into distinctive bread recipes that set you apart
- Buy efficient, off-the-shelf baking equipment to cut costs
- Improve customer service, since customers feel it directly
The point is to see where each part of your business stands so you can put effort and money where they count, and keep an eye on risks before they surprise you. Wardley also argues that each stage of evolution suits a different kind of team, an idea he calls pioneers, settlers and town planners.
Wardley Maps have a devoted following in tech and government strategy circles, but they are a practitioner's tool, not a validated method, and even fans admit their limits. The main objections:
"Evolution" implies more certainty than there is: In a 2017 blog post, Matt Edgar argues that components don't march neatly from genesis to commodity. They gain and lose visibility, and can move back from commodity toward novelty. Calling the horizontal axis "evolution" suggests a one-way, predictable process, which tempts people to treat maps as forecasts.
The two axes aren't independentEdgar also points out that how visible something is to the user and how commoditised it is tend to move together, which muddies what the map's position actually tells you.
Maps reflect opinion, not measurementWhere a component sits largely depends on the judgement and consensus of the people drawing the map. That makes mapping closer to a social exercise than a measurement, and people can nudge components around to suit an agenda.
An illusion of objectivityThe biggest risk, critics say, is that a neat diagram can turn assumptions into apparent facts and make it harder to challenge them. Wardley's answer is the reverse: the value of a map is that it exposes assumptions so they can be challenged, and he readily concedes that every map is an imperfect representation.
Thin evidence baseMuch of the theory was laid out in Wardley's own blog posts and an unfinished, freely licensed book. There are case studies (for example from UK government digital work), but no formal studies showing that teams who map make better decisions than teams who don't.
None of this makes mapping useless. Laying out what users need and how mature each part of the system is can spark exactly the right argument, much as a good SWOT analysis can. The fair reading is that a Wardley Map is a thinking aid and a conversation tool, at its best when the people drawing it stay honest about how much of it is guesswork.
Resources
Most strategy documents are stories. A Wardley Map is a map: something you can point at, argue over and use to see where things are heading. Created by Simon Wardley, it lays out the components of a business, project or system according to how directly they serve the user and how far each has evolved, so decision-makers can understand their landscape, spot opportunities and choose strategically. The tool draws on value chain analysis, situational awareness and the diffusion of innovations.
Here is how it connects to those and other ideas:
Value Chain AnalysisThe map's vertical axis is a value chain, inspired by Michael Porter's (1985) idea of breaking an organization into the activities that create value for the end user. User needs sit at the top; supporting infrastructure sits at the bottom.
Situational AwarenessA Wardley Map is fundamentally a tool for seeing your context clearly. It borrows from situational awareness, a concept in decision-making and risk management that stresses understanding your environment and how it is changing (Endsley, 1995).
Diffusion of InnovationsThe horizontal axis shows how components evolve, an idea influenced by Everett Rogers' (1962) diffusion of innovations theory, which explains how innovations spread through a population and become more standardized, eventually commoditized, over time. The same axis underpins Wardley's pioneers, settlers and town planners, which matches team attitudes to each stage of evolution.
Clayton Christensen's Disruptive InnovationMaps can help spot potential disruption, where a new product or service starts in a niche and eventually displaces established leaders (Christensen, 1997). By showing which components are ripe for change, a map points to openings for innovation and differentiation.
By combining these ideas into a single picture, Wardley Maps help decision-makers see their landscape and act on it, revealing chances for growth, innovation and disruption across many industries.
References
- Christensen, C. M. (1997). The Innovator's Dilemma: When New Technologies Cause Great Firms to Fail. Harvard Business Review Press.
- Endsley, M. R. (1995). Toward a theory of situation awareness in dynamic systems. Human Factors, 37(1), 32-64.
- Porter, M. E. (1985). Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance. Free Press.
- Rogers, E. M. (1962). Diffusion of Innovations. Free Press.
- Wardley, S. (2015). An Introduction to Wardley (Value Chain) Mapping. Bits or pieces? [Blog post]. Retrieved from https://blog.gardeviance.org/2015/02/an-introduction-to-wardley-value-chain.html