Pain vs Boredom Experiment

Pain vs Boredom Experiment

Left alone with nothing to do but think, many people chose to give themselves an electric shock rather than sit with their thoughts.

How far would you go to avoid being alone with your thoughts? Researchers at the University of Virginia and Harvard University wanted to find out, and the answer was: further than you'd think. Many people chose to give themselves an electric shock rather than sit and do nothing.

Here's how it worked.

Participants sat alone in a room for 6 to 15 minutes with no phone, no books and no entertainment of any kind. Their only job was to think. The one thing in the room was a button that delivered a mild electric shock.

Beforehand, everyone got a sample of the shock, and most said they would pay money not to feel it again. Yet once they were left alone with their thoughts, a significant number pressed the button anyway.

Picture someone a few minutes in, bored and fidgety. Rather than keep sitting there, they press the button and take the jolt they had sworn they'd pay to avoid.

The takeaway: many of us find our own company surprisingly hard to bear, so much so that a little pain beats a little boredom. The researchers suggest that in a world full of constant stimulation and distraction, we've grown less comfortable simply sitting with our own minds.

Reference:

  • Wilson, T. D., Reinhard, D. A., Westgate, E. C., Gilbert, D. T., Ellerbeck, N., Hahn, C., ... & Shaked, A. (2014). Just think: The challenges of the disengaged mind. Science, 345(6192), 75-77.

"People would rather be electrocuted than think" made a perfect headline in 2014. The underlying research is real, but the shock result is narrower and more debatable than the headline suggests. The main objections:

  1. The shock finding rests on a small studyThe self-shock experiment involved about 55 participants, far fewer than the hundreds who took part in the study's other experiments. The headline numbers (about two-thirds of men and a quarter of women pressed the button at least once) come from that small group, and one participant pressed it 190 times. Small samples with a striking split like this deserve caution until they're repeated.

  2. Was it pain, or something else?: The shocks were mild, and a self-delivered jolt you control may feel very different from one done to you. Science journalist Faye Flam (2014) questioned how much they really hurt and whether pressing the button reflected discomfort with one's thoughts or some other impulse. Plain curiosity about what the shock would feel like a second time is an obvious candidate, and the original study couldn't rule it out.

  3. "Hated being alone with their thoughts" overstates it: Participants rated thinking time around the middle of the scale, not as a torment. The fair reading is that sitting and thinking was less enjoyable than people expected, and less enjoyable than doing something, which is quite different from finding it unbearable.

  4. The core result replicates, the drama less soA large follow-up by Nicholas Buttrick, Timothy Wilson and colleagues (2019), with 2,557 participants at 12 sites in 11 countries, confirmed that people everywhere enjoyed doing everyday activities more than thinking for pleasure. That study focused on enjoyment, though, not on self-shocking, so the most famous part of the original has had much less direct testing.

  5. Boredom, not thinking as such, may be the driverNederkoorn and colleagues (2016) showed that people bored by a short film clip on repeat gave themselves more shocks than people watching a neutral documentary, especially those with a history of self-harm. That fits a broader story about boredom and the urge for any stimulation, rather than something special about being alone with your own mind.

  6. The technology explanation is speculativeThe idea that smartphones have eroded our tolerance for quiet is plausible, and Buttrick's team found that heavier phone users enjoyed thinking less. But that link is correlational, and the original study ran no test of it; it's easy to slip from correlation to cause here, the classic correlation-causation fallacy.

The experiment still makes a genuinely interesting point: most people find undirected thinking harder and less pleasant than they expect. Just hold the "pain over boredom" framing more loosely than the headlines did.

Resources

Given the choice between sitting quietly with their thoughts and giving themselves an electric shock, a surprising number of people reach for the shock. That is the striking finding of the Pain vs Boredom experiment by Wilson et al. (2014), which examined people's willingness to choose an aversive activity over being alone with their own minds. The study sheds light on mind-wandering and on how hard it is to engage in deliberate thought without any external stimulation.

The experiment connects to several areas of research:

  1. Mind-wanderingAttention drifts away from the current task or surroundings toward internally generated thoughts, memories or future plans. The experiment shows how hard people find it to steer their thoughts during these episodes.

  2. Attention and executive controlKeeping your focus on your own inner processes, with nothing external to latch on to, depends on attention and executive control, and the study shows how taxing that can be.

  3. Flow stateFlow is deep immersion in an activity where challenge and skill are in balance. With no external stimuli or engaging activity available, participants struggled to reach anything like flow and would rather endure something unpleasant than stay bored.

  4. Self-regulationThe study highlights how much self-regulation it takes to manage thoughts and emotions during inactivity or boredom, and how often people fall short.

  5. Effects of technology and media consumptionThe findings raise questions about how technology and media affect our tolerance for boredom and introspection. In an era of constant connectivity, people may come to rely ever more on outside stimulation, making it harder to simply be alone with their thoughts.

References

  • Wilson, T. D., Reinhard, D. A., Westgate, E. C., Gilbert, D. T., Ellerbeck, N., Hahn, C., ... & Shaked, A. (2014). Just think: The challenges of the disengaged mind. Science, 345(6192), 75-77.
  • Smallwood, J., & Schooler, J. W. (2015). The science of mind wandering: empirically navigating the stream of consciousness. Annual Review of Psychology, 66, 487-518.
  • Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1990). Flow: The psychology of optimal experience. Harper & Row.
  • Baumeister, R. F., & Vohs, K. D. (Eds.). (2004). Handbook of self-regulation: Research, theory, and applications. Guilford Press.
  • Turkle, S. (2011). Alone together: Why we expect more from technology and less from each other. Basic Books.